I Looked at What Women Are Saving on Pinterest—These Are the 10 NYE Outfits That Keep Showing Up

Photo Credit:@nicholelynel

New Year’s Eve has a way of sneaking up on you — especially when you live somewhere cold. In cities like Chicago, the snow, slush, and wind instantly take the drama out of the “glam night out” fantasy. Suddenly sequins feel unnecessary, strappy heels feel unserious, and the only thing you’re sure about is that you’d like to feel cute and sane at the same time.

Most people aren’t going to a black-tie countdown. They’re headed to a friend’s apartment, a house party, a casual dinner, or ringing in midnight from someone’s living room. And that’s why casual New Year’s Eve outfits have become the real stars of the night.

You want something that says “I didn’t overthink this” but still looks intentional in photos. Something you can wear while pouring champagne, sitting on a couch, stepping outside for a minute, or joining a last-minute house-party invite. Basically: cute casual outfits for New Year’s Eve that work for real life, not a movie set.

So here are 10 New Years Outfit ideas that feel fun, easy, and still NYE-worthy — without the pressure to “dress up” in a way that doesn’t match the night.

Start the new year off with this 365 visual outfit guide with outfits for every day and every occasion

Here’s What To Read Next:

After Styling Corporate Women for 10 Years, Here’s What They Wear to Work in the Winter

Women In Their 50s Couldn’t Stop Wearing These 20 Pieces in 2025

1. The Soft Sweater + Leather Pants Look

There’s something about pairing a cozy knit with sleek faux-leather pants that feels festive without even trying. It’s warm, comfortable, and still gives the outfit that “I put in effort” confidence. Perfect for house parties where you want to feel relaxed and dressed up at the same time.

MAJORELLE

Cici Faux Fur Collar Cardigan
$198

LAMARQUE

Shannon Pant

$545

Dolce Vita

Kanika Pointed Toe Pump

$150

2. The Oversized Button-Down + Sparkly Earrings Combo

This is the girl who doesn’t want sequins but still wants a moment. A crisp button-down, a good pair of jeans, and earrings that catch the light do all the work. It feels unfussy and grown, but still New Year’s Eve enough to take photos in.

Norma Kamali

Oversized Boyfriend Shirt Bodysuit

$275

Amazon

Wide Leg Jeans High Waisted Strechy Raw Hem

$39.99

Amazon

Small Bow Earrings

$7.99

3. The Simple Slip Dress + Chunky Sweater

If you want to wear a dress without freezing, this is the trick. The sweater softens the shine of the slip and makes the outfit feel cozy instead of formal. The movement of the dress still gives you that NYE feeling, even if you’re at a casual house gathering.

Amazon

2 Piece Soft Sweater Dress with an Elegant Lace-Trim

$35.88

Amazon

Chunky Heel Square Toe Heeled Boots

$59.99

4. The Black Turtleneck + Statement Coat

This is for the woman who knows she’s stepping outside at some point. The turtleneck keeps you warm, and the coat becomes the outfit. Whether it’s faux fur, a bold color, or a fun print, it makes you feel instantly put-together with zero effort underneath.

SKIMS

Stretch Cotton Jersey Turtleneck Top

$64.00

Citizens of Humanity

Ayla High Waist Baggy Wide Leg Jeans

$238.00

Amazon

Fluffy Faux Fur Jacket

$66.98

5. The Matching Lounge Set That Looks Intentional

A matching knit set always reads elevated, even when it’s technically loungewear. Add a glossy lip and gold hoops, and suddenly it feels like the perfect casual New Year’s Eve outfit for staying in, hosting friends, or watching the ball drop on the couch.

Amazon

2 Piece Skirt Sets

$58.99

6. The Bodysuit + Wide-Leg Jeans

Classic, clean, and always flattering. The bodysuit creates a smooth base, the jeans bring comfort, and it all just feels easy. Add a clutch or fun shoe if you want a touch of sparkle, but the outfit stands on its own.

Amazon

Long Sleeve Bodysuit

$34.99

Amazon

Women's High-Rise Wide Leg Cuffed Jean

$29.90

7. The Sequin Top You Only Wear Once a Year + Your Everyday Jeans

This is the “yes, I’ll participate but I’m still comfortable” look. The jeans keep you grounded, while the top brings the fun. It’s the ideal balance when you want to feel festive without fully committing.

Amazon

Mesh Sheer Top

$9.99

Citizens of Humanity

Annina Wide Leg Jeans

$238

8. The Cardigan You Love + Silk Skirt

This blend of textures works every time. The cardigan brings softness and the skirt brings movement. It feels romantic without being dressy, and you can layer tights and boots if it’s freezing out.

MAJORELLE

Lilyana Cardigan

$189

Lovers and Friends

Mariah Mini Skirt

$128

9. The Monochrome Outfit in Your Favorite Color

Wearing one color head-to-toe instantly looks intentional, even if it’s just a sweater and leggings. It photographs beautifully and feels sleek without trying. Add a bold lip if you want a little glam.

Petal & Pup

Ellory Knit Tank & Pants Set

$109.00

10. The Casual Dress + Tall Boots

This is an easy “I want to look cute without thinking about it” outfit. The boots frame the dress, give structure, and make the outfit feel winter-friendly. It’s casual, warm, and flattering on every body.

Petal & Pup

Farrow Long Sleeve Midi Dress

$89.00

Vince Camuto

Gylina Knee High Boot

$275

Start the new year off with this 365 visual outfit guide with outfits for every day and every occasion

Here’s What To Read Next:

After Styling Corporate Women for 10 Years, Here’s What They Wear to Work in the Winter

Women In Their 50s Couldn’t Stop Wearing These 20 Pieces in 2025