Old Navy Try-On Haul for Midsize Women: What Actually Worked on My 5’1” Frame
Every summer, the hunt begins: finding shorts and pants that don’t ride up, cut into your waist, or make you want to change the second you sit down.
So I placed a little Old Navy haul—mostly bottoms, plus one top that ended up going with everything—and tried everything on to see what worked, what didn’t, and what’s officially staying in heavy rotation.
If you’ve been looking for affordable midsize summer clothes or just wondering what’s worth buying at Old Navy right now, this is it. I’m sharing fit notes, honest feedback, and how each piece felt on my 5’1” midsize frame—so you can skip the guesswork.
More Guides For When You Don’t Know What To Wear
The Amazon Pieces That Made My Closet Feel New Again
I Always Overpack for Road Trips—Here’s What I’m Actually Bringing This Time
I Built My Entire Spring Wardrobe from Amazon—Here’s What I Bought
The Best Amazon Jeans for Short Women (I’m 5’1” and These Fit)
Why Your Outfits Feel “Off” (And the Easy Fixes That Actually Work)
I Reach for These 30 Amazon Pieces When I Have Nothing to Wear
The Top That Goes With Everything
This was the only top in my Old Navy summer try-on, and somehow it goes with every single pair of pants and shorts in this post.
It’s lightweight, stretchy, and super flattering. If you’re in between sizes, go smaller—there’s a lot of stretch. I grabbed a Medium and it fits perfectly.
Busty girl tip: If button gaps are usually a thing, size up. The buttons are real.
Button-Down Ribbed Tank (Size M)
$19.99
The Shorts That Don’t Ride Up
I bought two colors because I finally found shorts that work for midsize, curvy thighs. They’re roomy, flattering, and just long enough to feel confident wearing to the park with my kids.
If you’re short and curvy (I’m 5’1”), these are worth trying. They don’t dig into your legs when you sit, and they style perfectly with a basic tank or tee.
High-Waisted Baggy Jean Shorts (Size 14 – Light Wash & Elizabeth Light)
$39.99
The Leggings I Should’ve Sized Down In
These Old Navy activewear leggings are soft and stretchy with convenient side pockets that fit a phone (sort of—I wouldn’t jog with it).
That said, I should’ve gone with a Large. They’re wearable, but I find myself pulling them up throughout the day.
PowerSoft 7/8 Pocket Leggings (Size XL – Black Jack)
$39.99
The Unexpected Favorite
These are ultra-lightweight, breathable, and perfect for hot weather.
I’d go for a darker color if you’re worried about sweat, but the comfort is unmatched. These give elevated jogger energy and definitely feel like Old Navy summer outfit essentials if you’re on the go.
High-Waisted SleekTech Barrel Ankle Pants (Size L – Savanna Grass)
$39.99
The Best Jeans for Sitting All Day
Hands down, these are the best Old Navy jeans for curvy women who work from home. They’re flowy like linen, breathable, and have a drawstring waistband—aka built-in comfort.
They don’t cut into your belly, don’t gap in the back, and don’t feel stiff like typical denim. I’m wearing these on repeat.
High-Waisted Super Wide-Leg Drapey Jeans (Size 14 – Dark Wash)
$49.99
Sizing Recap (for reference)
Height: 5’1”
Bottoms: Size 14
Tops: Medium (with stretch)
Body Type: Midsize, short torso, curvy thighs, and a soft midsection
If you’re wondering what to buy from Old Navy right now, these pieces are a great place to start—especially if you’re midsize, short, or just tired of guessing at fit.
This Old Navy try-on review gave me a solid summer capsule without spending a fortune. I’ll definitely be grabbing a few tops and dresses next (because their linen collection has been living in my head rent-free).
Want more real-girl style hauls and sizing reviews? Let me know and I’ll keep them coming.
